Leather or Textile Walking and Hiking Boots
Q. I can't decide on whether to buy textile or leather boots. Any opinions on which is generally regarded as better?
Eamonn McGuinness, Bedford
A. I imagine that everyone will have their own ideas on this subject, and that every idea will be different, but before we can offer a suggestion we need to consider what kind of surface the boots will be used on. Will it be bare, sharp, rock; will it be rough trails; or will it be muddy moorland?
On bare rock, leather will offer greater strength and a stiffer ankle support than a fabric boot; for muddy moorland, a leather boot can be kept waterproof more easily than can a fabric one. The downside is that a leather boot will probably be heavier than a fabric one, and leather needs (and deserves!) frequent care and cleaning to keep it in good condition.
For rough trail walking, a fabric boot will be lighter, will be easier to wash if it gets muddy, and will require less maintenance. I would recommend that a fabric boot should have a sealed gusset around the tongue; if the tongue is loose, then there is no chance at all of making the boot waterproof.
These are, of course, generalisations; no doubt various manufactureres will claim that their fabric boots can out-perform leather ones, and vice-versa!
There are also many boots and trail shoes on the market that are hybrids of leather and fabric, and a first-time buyer would probably be best advised to chose such a boot.
My own current pair of boots, which are the most comfortable and efficient that I have ever had, came from Famous Army Stores five years ago for a mere £40. Hardly top-of-the-range, but I love them!
They are substantially leather, with fabric side panels and a cushioned fabric tongue and gusset. I treat them to Nikwax Fabric and Leather proofing whenever they have been in water/mud, and they have never yet let let in water from the outside.
I only possess the one pair of boots, and so they have to do the full range of surfaces - Snowdon, Kinder Scout, and the Samaria Gorge.
They have been faultless, and I would certainly buy another hybrid boot when replacement becomes necessary.
Ron Linton, Cheadle Hulme
Add an answer THIS question | Ask a NEW walking and hiking question
Return to the main list of Walking and Hiking Questions
Search for an existing Walking and Hiking Question or Answer
To contribute to go4awalk.com or to contact us about anything at all
- see Talk To Us. For help see Help.
NB. To see our navigational hills you must have the Macromedia Shockwave/Flash Player plug-in installed in your browser. This is free and comes as standard with later versions. If you have an early version browser - click here and follow Macromedia's installation instructions.
go4awalk.com and go4awalk.co.uk are registered trademarks of TMDH Limited.
Copyright © 2000-2010 TMDH Limited. All rights reserved.
Copyright | Terms & Conditions | Privacy Statement
A - Z Walks Home Log On / Accounts Photo Gallery
Walk Ideas and Collections Fell Facts Places to Stay Hill Skills
Walking Questions and Answers Your Stories News Competitions
Product Reviews/Gear Tests Walking Gear Guides Contents
Peaks and Mountains Peak Bagging Find New Walking Friends
Ordnance Survey Walking Maps Camping GPS Waypoints for Walking
Walk Search Talk to us go4awalk.com Help Free example walks
